When you think of Ohio State football, the legacy runs deep—from Archie Griffin’s unprecedented two Heisman trophies to the relentless toughness of Buckeye legends like Chris Spielman and Eddie George. But the Tressel era, spanning 2001 to 2010, carved its own indelible mark on the program’s storied history. It was a decade of hard-nosed defense, clutch performances, and national championships. Today, we dive headfirst into the best players of the Tressel era, rank the top 4 Ohio State players during that time, compare the best Buckeye quarterbacks, and explore the debates that still fuel passionate conversations among fans.
The Ohio State Football Mount Rushmore: Where Does the Tressel Era Fit?
The concept of the Ohio State football Mount Rushmore is a perennial debate, with names like Archie Griffin, Eddie George, and Orlando Pace regularly etched into the collective imagination of Buckeye Nation. But where do the stars of the Tressel era fit in? Should players like Troy Smith — the best Ohio State quarterback ever according to many — or stalwarts like Chris Spielman, who epitomized toughness, make the cut?
While the all-time legends like Griffin and Pace often dominate the discussions, the Tressel era gifted us with a unique blend of championship pedigree and individual excellence. The 2002 Ohio State championship team, led by Craig Krenzel and featuring a defense that owned Michigan, set a standard that few have matched since.
Ranking the Tressel Era’s Top 5 Players
Let’s get into the heart of it—the Tressel Five. Ranking players from a decade filled with talent is no easy task, given the mix of offensive dynamos, defensive juggernauts, and clutch leaders. Here’s my passionate take on the best Buckeyes from 2001–2010.
Troy Smith (QB, 2003-2006)Troy Smith’s name is synonymous with brilliance and clutch moments . Winning the Heisman in 2006, he’s often at the center of the debate: Is Troy Smith the best OSU QB ever? His combination of arm talent, mobility, and leadership under pressure — especially in rivalry games against Michigan — cemented his legacy. Smith was the engine of the offense and a clutch Ohio State quarterback who delivered time and again. Chris Spielman (LB, 1984-1987) – honorary mention for toughness and leadership
Though Spielman’s prime was before the Tressel era, his speeches and spirit inspired the teams of the 2000s. Known as one of the toughest Ohio State players ever, Spielman’s legacy loomed large, influencing the physicality and resilience of Tressel’s defenses. Orlando Pace (OT, 1996-1999) – bridging eras
Pace’s dominance on the offensive line helped set the tone for future Buckeye offensive linemen. Known as the most dominant college offensive lineman, his blocking prowess and pancake blocks made him the prototype for the best Ohio State offensive linemen of the Tressel era that followed. Eddie George (RB, 1992-1995) – for context and comparison
Though predating Tressel, Eddie George’s legendary 1995 season and Heisman-winning campaign often get compared to later Buckeye running backs. His highlights and sheer workhorse ability set the standard for players like Beanie Wells and Ezekiel Elliott. The perennial debate of Eddie George vs Zeke remains a favorite among fans dissecting the best Ohio State running back and best Ohio State running back seasons. Malcolm Jenkins (DB, 2006-2008) – underrated Buckeye player
Jenkins was one of the most underrated Buckeyes of the Tressel era. A versatile defensive back who could shut down receivers and make game-changing plays, he deserves more credit in conversations about the best Ohio State players of this time.
Of course, this list is subjective, and others would argue for players like Beanie Wells, A.J. Hawk, or Santonio Holmes. But the blend of leadership, talent, and clutch performances that these five brought to Columbus is undeniable.
Quarterback Comparisons: Troy Smith vs Justin Fields
One of the hottest debates in recent Ohio State history — and an important lens to view Tressel-era greatness — is the comparison between Troy Smith and Justin Fields. While Fields played well after Tressel’s tenure, drawing parallels helps frame the evolution of Ohio State quarterbacks.
Troy Smith was a dynamic, dual-threat QB with a knack for making plays when it mattered most. His 2006 Heisman season was an electrifying mix of passing and rushing prowess, and he was known for his calm under pressure — especially in rivalry games. Smith was a clutch Ohio State quarterback, delivering memorable performances against Michigan and in bowl games.
Justin Fieldsbest Ohio State performances against Michigan ever recorded, with clutch plays that rivaled the best in program history.
So, who wins the troy smith vs justin fields debate? It depends on your criteria. Smith’s leadership and Heisman pedigree make him a strong candidate for best Ohio State quarterback ever, while Fields’s raw talent and statistical dominance point toward a bright future in Buckeye lore. Both deserve recognition as icons of their respective eras.
Ohio State Dream Team Offense: Who Makes the Cut?
When you imagine the Ohio State all-time offense or the Ohio State dream team offense, certain names inevitably rise to the top. The Buckeyes have produced some of the best Ohio State offensive players in college football history, and choosing an all-star lineup is a delightful challenge.
- Quarterback: Troy Smith (for leadership and clutch ability) or Craig Krenzel (2002 championship grit) Running Back: Eddie George (1995 season dominance) or Ezekiel Elliott (explosive, versatile) Wide Receiver: Santonio Holmes (game-changing plays and speed) Offensive Line: Orlando Pace (the most dominant offensive lineman in Ohio State history), plus other greats like Jim Parker and Jack Mewhort
This lineup blends eras but reflects the heart of what makes Buckeye offense so special: toughness, talent, and the ability to rise to the occasion. The 2002 Ohio State championship team, sometimes nicknamed the Luckeyes due to their clutch plays and fortunate breaks, exemplified this spirit, with players like Krenzel and the offensive line owning the trenches.
Forgotten Ohio State Legends and Underrated Buckeyes
Every storied program has its Ohio State players who deserve more credit and forgotten Ohio State legends. The Tressel era is no exception. Players like Malcolm Jenkins, Beanie Wells, and even some of the defensive stalwarts didn’t always get the national recognition they deserved but were absolutely vital to Buckeye success.
Chris Spielman’s speeches and leadership continue to inspire, and his legacy as one of the Ohio State linebacker legends underscores the tradition of toughness that Tressel’s teams embodied. Beanie Wells, for example, was a powerful running back who consistently delivered best Ohio State performances against Michigan, often in physically punishing games.
Will Anyone Win Two Heismans Again? Archie Griffin’s Unique Place
Archie Griffin stands alone in college football history as the only player to have won two Heisman trophies. His name is forever etched as the greatest college player Ohio State has ever produced. The question remains: Will anyone win two Heismans again? The increasing specialization and competition in college football make it highly unlikely, cementing Griffin’s place atop the Click for info Ohio State legends Mt Rushmore.
Yet, the Tressel era produced its own Heisman winners — Troy Smith among them — and a slew of players who came close or could have been in the conversation. Ohio State’s ability to nurture Heisman-caliber talent remains a hallmark of the program.
you know,Final Thoughts: The Legacy of the Tressel Era and Beyond
Ranking the best players of the Tressel era is a thrilling journey through a decade of grit, glory, and unforgettable moments. From Troy Smith’s Heisman heroics to the defensive toughness inspired by legends like Chris Spielman, this era defined modern Ohio State football. Comparing quarterbacks, debating the all-time teams, and honoring underrated Ohio State players enriches the ongoing conversation that every Buckeye fan loves.
Ohio State’s history is layered, with legends bridging generations—from Archie Griffin’s unmatched accomplishments to the dynamic stars of the Tressel era and beyond. Whether you’re a fan of the 2002 Fiesta Bowl facts and the championship team or you revel in the exploits of Elliott and Wells, one thing is clear: Ohio State football’s legacy is built on excellence, resilience, and a relentless pursuit of greatness.
So, who’s on your Ohio State football Mount Rushmore? How do you rank the top 4 Ohio State players and the best four Buckeye players ever? For Buckeye Nation, the debates never end — and that’s just the way we like it.
Written by a passionate Buckeye fan and historian, reliving the glory days of Ohio State football and celebrating the legends who defined the program.